| Rank | Moment | |
|---|
| 1 | Shot Heard 'Round the World | |
| 2 | Bill Mazeroski's Home Run | |
| 3 | Don Larsen's Perfect Game | |
| 4 | Carlton Fisk Waves It Fair | |
| 5 | Hank Aaron's 715th Home Run | |
| 6 | Kirk Gibson's Home Run | |
| 7 | Mark McGwire Hits No. 62 | |
| 8 | E-3 on Bill Buckner | |
| 9 | Willie Mays' Catch | |
| 10 | Enos Slaughter's Mad Dash | |
| 11 | The Luckiest Man Alive Speech | |
| 12 | Reggie Jackson's Three Homers | |
| 13 | Willie McCovey Lines Out | |
| 14 | Bucky Dent's Home Run | |
| 15 | Roger Maris hits No. 61 | |
| 16 | Joe Carter's Home Run | |
| 17 | Cal Ripken breaks Gehrig's Streak | |
| 18 | Brooklyn wins the World Series | |
| 19 | Haddix's Perfect Loss | |
| 20 | Pete Rose gets hit No. 4,192 | |
| 21 | Chris Chambliss' Home Run | |
| 22 | George Brett's Home Run | |
| 23 | Owen and the Dropped Third Strike | |
| 24 | Dave Henderson's Home Run | |
| 25 | Cookie Lavagetto beats Bill Bevens | |