| 1975 | Academy Award for Actor in a Leading Role, Al Pacino |
| 1975 | Academy Award for Best Director, Sidney Lumet |
| 1975 | Academy Award for Best Picture, Martin Elfand |
| 1975 | Academy Award for Best Original Screenplay, Frank Pierson |
| 1975 | Academy Award for Actor in a Supporting Role, Chris Sarandon |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Actor in a Leading Role, Al Pacino |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Direction, Sidney Lumet |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Film, Sidney Lumet |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Director - Film, Sidney Lumet |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Actor - Drama Film, Al Pacino |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actor - Film, John Cazale |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actor - Film, Charles Durning |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Drama Film, Martin Bregman |
| 1975 | DGA Award for Outstanding Directorial Achievement in Feature Film, Sidney Lumet |
| 1976 | Golden Globe Award for Best Screenplay - Motion Picture, Frank Pierson |
| 1975 | Academy Award for Film Editing, Dede Allen |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Editing, Dede Allen |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Screenplay, Frank Pierson |
| 1975 | BAFTA Award for Best Sound, Jack Fitzstephens |