| Year | Song | Songwriter | |
|---|
| 2009 | Down to Earth | Peter Gabriel, Thomas Newman | |
| 2008 | Love You I Do | Siedah Garrett, Henry Krieger | |
| 2007 | Our Town | Randy Newman | |
| 2006 | Believe | Glen Ballard, Alan Silvestri | |
| 2005 | Into the West | Annie Lennox, Howard Shore, Fran Walsh | |
| 2004 | A Mighty Wind | Christopher Guest, Eugene Levy, Michael McKean | |
| 2003 | If I Didn't Have You | Randy Newman | |
| 2002 | Boss of Me | John Flansburgh, John Linnell | |
| 2001 | When She Loved Me | Randy Newman | |
| 2000 | Beautiful Stranger | Madonna, William Orbit | |
| 1999 | My Heart Will Go On | James Horner, Will Jennings | |
| 1998 | I Believe I Can Fly | R. Kelly | |
| 1997 | Because You Loved Me | Diane Warren | |
| 1996 | Colors of the Wind | Alan Menken, Stephen Schwartz | |
| 1995 | Streets of Philadelphia | Bruce Springsteen | |
| 1994 | A Whole New World | Alan Menken, Tim Rice | |
| 1993 | Beauty and the Beast | Howard Ashman, Alan Menken | |
| 1992 | (Everything I Do) I Do It For You | Robert John Lange, Michael Kamen, Bryan Adams | |
| 1991 | Under the Sea | Howard Ashman | |
| 1990 | Let the River Run | Carly Simon | |
| 1989 | Two Hearts | Phil Collins, Lamont Dozier | |
| 1988 | Somewhere Out There | James Horner, Barry Mann, Cynthia Weil | |