| 2008 | Academy Award for Actor in a Leading Role, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Academy Award for Actress in a Supporting Role, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | BAFTA Award for Best Actor in a Leading Role, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | BAFTA Award for Best Actress in a Supporting Role, Marisa Tomei |
| 2009 | Golden Globe Award for Best Actor - Drama Film, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Golden Globe Award for Best Supporting Actress - Film, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | BFCA Critics' Choice Award for Best Picture |
| 2008 | BFCA Critics' Choice Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Satellite Award for Best Actor – Motion Picture Drama, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Costume Designers Guild Award for Best Costume Design - Contemporary Film, Amy Westcott |
| 2009 | Independent Spirit Award for Best Cinematography, Maryse Alberti |
| 2009 | Independent Spirit Award for Best Male Lead, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | BFCA Critics' Choice Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2009 | Independent Spirit Award for Best Feature, Scott Franklin |
| 2009 | Screen Actors Guild Award for Best Actor - Motion Picture, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | ADG Excellence in Production Design Awards - Contemporary Film, Matthew Munn |
| 2009 | David di Donatello for Best Foreign Film, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2009 | Golden Globe Award for Best Original Song, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2008 | BFCA Critics' Choice Award for Best Song, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2008 | San Francisco Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | San Francisco Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Satellite Award for Best Original Song, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2008 | Boston Society of Film Critics Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2010 | Bodil Award for Best American Film, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2010 | Japan Academy Award for Best Foreign Film |
| 2008 | London Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | London Film Critics Circle Award for Best Director, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2008 | London Film Critics Circle Award for Best Film |
| 2009 | Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | Phoenix Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | Phoenix Film Critics Society Award for Best Original Song, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2009 | Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award for Best Director, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2009 | Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Original Screenplay, Robert D. Siegel |
| 2009 | Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Picture |
| 2008 | Las Vegas Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2009 | Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Director, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2008 | Gotham Independent Film Award for Best Film, Scott Franklin |
| 2008 | Florida Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Chlotrudis Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Chicago Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Central Ohio Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Prism Award for Performance in a Feature Film, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | Online Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2009 | Prism Award for Feature Film |
| 2009 | MTV Movie Award for Best Song From a Movie, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2009 | British Independent Film Award for Best Foreign Independent FIlm |
| 2009 | Central Ohio Film Critics Association Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2009 | ESPY Award for Best Sports Movie |
| 2009 | Artios for Best Casting for Feature Film, Drama, Mary Vernieu |
| 2009 | Kansas City Film Critics Circle Award for Best Original Screenplay, Robert D. Siegel |
| 2008 | San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Supporting Actress, Marisa Tomei |
| 2008 | Toronto Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2008 | Golden Lion, Darren Aronofsky |
| 2008 | Washington D.C. Area Film Critics Association Award for Best Actor, Mickey Rourke |
| 2009 | World Soundtrack Award for Best Original Song Written Directly for a Film, Bruce Springsteen |
| 2009 | Writers Guild of America Award for Best Original Screenplay, Robert D. Siegel |